HDRC Solutions

A more recent development in high density rack cooling is the shift from data center space conditioning to directly cooling the server racks within the space. Several current system designs are available for low, medium and high density rack cooling:

In-Row Server Cooling

This is a cooling cabinet matching the height & depth of the server racks and installed between the server racks, spaced to approximately match the heat load. The in-row cooler includes a cooling coil and fans. Air is drawn over the coil and delivered it back into the room as cooled air.

In-row coolers are predominantly chilled water cooled but are also available with pumped refrigerant. In all cases either a mechanical chiller or a building chilled water heat exchanger are required to reject the heat from the in-row coolers absorb from the aisle space. In some cases in-row coolers can be spaced every 3 or 4 racks but in high density rack cooling applications they may be required on a one-for-one spacing.

These systems are most effective when used in conjunction with CRAC units and a hot/cold aisle containment system. When viewed as a complete system, the combination of in-row coolers, hot/cold aisle containment systems and CRAC units can often require more floor space than is available or reduce the future expansion possibilities. While this system can provide effective high density rack cooling it is unlikely to reduce energy consumption.

Top-Hat Fan Cartridges

These are fan boxes mounted on top of the server racks, towards the rear with an EC (VFD) fan that increases air flow across the server rack, based on heat load. Top-hat fan boxes can be ducted back to the HVAC system above the racks (headroom permitting) with the same air flow separation characteristics provided by an aisle containment system described above.

These systems have achieved some success but are dependent on the existing (or new) air conditioning and air distribution system within the room since they do not include any cooling plant or equipment. Power savings are realized by fan power energy reduction in the data center air conditioning system, off-set by the added fan power installed in these systems. The energy limitation of this systems is that it must transfer the server heat to the air, which must then be cooled in a CRAC or air handler before the heat is finally rejected in a chiller.

Passive Rear Door Cooling

Virtually all servers draw room air from the front and discharge it to the rear. Passive rear doors can remove heat at its source without taking up any additional floor space. A passive rear door cooler is comprised of a chilled water cooling coil installed in the rear door of the server rack. The existing server fans draw room air across the servers and discharge the hot air across the cooling coil in the rear door where the heat is transferred to the chilled water which is piped outside to the chiller or heat exchanger. This works well if the passive rear door cooler can handle the maximum heat output from the servers with the fixed airflow from the server fans.

Passive rear door coolers were originally developed for IBM servers, which have a design airflow at the high end of the industry scale. The current volume server producers generally have a lower airflow which reduces the effectiveness of passive rear door coolers. The current server design trend is to reduce the fan motor size in order to limit the server power consumption in a fiercely competitive industry. This is made possible by wider operating temperature limits now suggested by most server manufacturers.

The current limitation of a passive rear door cooler is about 20kW and is subject to specific chilled water temperature, optimum server fan air flow, room air temperature and initial temperature differential (ITD) between the entering air and the chilled water. In most cases passive rear door coolers are limited to low and medium rack cooling and not suitable for high density rack cooling.

Active Rear Door Coolers

Bolt-on Active Rear Door Coolers (Chilled Water): These occupy about ½ of the rear door surface area and include a chilled water coil and a row of fans to increase the airflow across the servers and the cooling coil. Because they are attached to the existing rear door of the server rack these coolers have a restricted coil area and limited fan capacity. These coolers are limited to about 8 kW server heat removal capacity and are therefore not suitable for high density rack cooling.

Active Rear Door Coolers (Pumped Refrigerant): These coolers include a pumped refrigerant coil and fans. The server heat is absorbed into the refrigerant which is then piped outside to a mechanical chiller to reject the heat. Alternatively the refrigerant can be piped to a heat exchanger so the heat can be rejected to the building chilled water supply. Pumped refrigerant rear door coolers are limited to a maximum of 30 kW cooling capacity.

Active Rear Door Coolers (Chilled Water): These effectively replace the rear door of the server rack with a full-size chilled water cooling coil and multiple EC (variable speed) fans. Motivair Chilled Door high density rack coolers are available up to 45 kW capacity per rack and therefore suitable for a wide range of racks and especially suitable for high density rack cooling.


Recommendations

By removing heat at its source before it enters the server room, active rear door coolers or a Chilled Door System can monitor and adjust cooling performance by varying fan speed, chilled water temperature and flow. The energy savings from using chilled water up to 68F instead of the traditional 44F decreases chiller size and energy consumption by 35%. By pairing active rear door coolers with a Free Cooling Chiller (or alternative cooling source) the operating cost savings are increased to 93% depending on the site location.

The efficiency of all active rear door high density rack cooling systems can be greatly improved by utilizing chilled water or refrigerant at the highest possible temperature. While the industry standard (ARI and ASHRAE) chilled water supply temperature is 44-45F, active rear door rack coolers are best designed for 60-65F entering chilled water. This insures 100% sensible cooling at all times and avoids any accidental de-humidification and subsequent re-humidification, both of which consume power unnecessarily. The greatest savings however are achieved by operating any type or brand of chiller at 60-65F leaving water temperature. The kW per ton required by any chiller is reduced by 30-35% compared to operating the same chiller with 45F leaving chilled water. Operating passive rear door coolers with 60-65F chilled water severely limits their cooling capacity because of inadequate (server) airflow. CRAC units and custom air handling systems are not designed or suitable for 60-65F chilled water.

Even greater energy savings can be achieved when the data center chiller is fitted with an integrated free cooling chiller system that allows reduced or eliminated compressor operation during periods of lower outside air temperature. When supplying chilled water (entering the rack cooler) at 65F, a free cooling chiller can provide 100% cooling capacity without compressor operation at 45F outside ambient temperature. During this period the chiller operating cost is reduced by about 85%, using only the required VFD fan power in the chiller. In the Central & Northern United States, Canada, Central & Northern Europe the annual energy savings using 65F supply chilled water and a free cooling chiller can reach 93% compared to a traditional CRAC chilled water cooling system. Air-cooled free cooling chillers are available to 350 tons and have the added advantage of eliminating water use and water treatment for cooling towers.

Best practice for a state-of-the-art high density rack cooling system is a data center without a raised floor and all overhead mechanical & structured electrical services. Active rear door coolers should be rated for the full server load plus a reasonable anticipated growth factor. The rear door coolers should each be fitted with independent PLC controls that allow them to control each rack plus the entire data center space temperature without the use of hot or cold aisles, CRAC units or other air handlers.

The active rear door coolers should be supplied with chilled water at 65F from packaged air-cooled free cooling chillers located outside the building and designed to provide 100% free cooling at an outside ambient temperature of 50-55F. The result is a lower cost installation with dramatically reduced electrical operating cost. Data center reliability is increased with the use of an independent active rear door cooler per rack. Chiller redundancy should be a minimum of N +1.

Questions? Feel free to ask us for more information.